Ana-Lucia killed 2 "good people?"

[h***@animail.net]

Isn't that what Henry said? One of them was clearly Goodwin, but who
was the other? Shannon? Was someone supposed to get Shannon (as Henry
was sent for Locke) because she was now "good," and Ana-Lucia killed
her first? Or did she kill some other Other that I've forgotten about?

I find this sending someone to get the "good ones" business very
interesting. It could suggest a real afterlife scenario, or more
likely, some flapsquiddle cult (Hanso and co.) that are making these
calls thinking they're fulfilling a holy cause of some sort.

himiko

[Kim]

Post by h***@animail.net
Isn't that what Henry said? One of them was clearly Goodwin, but who
was the other? Shannon?

No, the night the "Others" took the kids she bashed in some girl's (I think
it was a girl) head with a rock. The same night that Eko killed the two men.
I think that was the second person Henry was speaking of.

[Drax]

Post by h***@animail.net
Isn't that what Henry said? One of them was clearly Goodwin, but who
was the other? Shannon? Was someone supposed to get Shannon (as Henry
was sent for Locke) because she was now "good," and Ana-Lucia killed
her first? Or did she kill some other Other that I've forgotten about?
himiko

I think he means the girl Ana-Lucia hit with a rock when the Others
attack them on the beach.

[Steven L.]

Post by Drax

Post by h***@animail.net
Isn't that what Henry said? One of them was clearly Goodwin, but who
was the other? Shannon? Was someone supposed to get Shannon (as Henry
was sent for Locke) because she was now "good," and Ana-Lucia killed
her first? Or did she kill some other Other that I've forgotten about?
himiko

I think he means the girl Ana-Lucia hit with a rock when the Others
attack them on the beach.

Right. After killing that woman, Ana-Lucia then searched thru her
clothing and found the Army knife and the list of nine on her person.

[Broken Spirit v2.0]

Well, Ecko confessed to killing two of them to Henry, and I couldn't figure
out why he did, unless he figured a stranger would be a good person to
confess to. So if Ana Lucia killed two "good" people, then I guess Ecko did
too, and so I wonder what will happen to him.

Post by Steven L.
Right. After killing that woman, Ana-Lucia then searched thru her
clothing and found the Army knife and the list of nine on her person.
--
Steven D. Litvintchouk
Remove the NOSPAM before replying to me.

[idiscuss]

Eko is going to die too according to the preview.

Post by Broken Spirit v2.0
Well, Ecko confessed to killing two of them to Henry, and I couldn't figure
out why he did, unless he figured a stranger would be a good person to
confess to. So if Ana Lucia killed two "good" people, then I guess Ecko did
too, and so I wonder what will happen to him.

Post by Steven L.
Right. After killing that woman, Ana-Lucia then searched thru her
clothing and found the Army knife and the list of nine on her person.
--
Steven D. Litvintchouk
Remove the NOSPAM before replying to me.

[h***@animail.net]

Post by Steven L.

Post by Drax

Post by h***@animail.net
Isn't that what Henry said? One of them was clearly Goodwin, but who
was the other? Shannon? Was someone supposed to get Shannon (as Henry
was sent for Locke) because she was now "good," and Ana-Lucia killed
her first? Or did she kill some other Other that I've forgotten about?
himiko

I think he means the girl Ana-Lucia hit with a rock when the Others
attack them on the beach.

Right. After killing that woman, Ana-Lucia then searched thru her
clothing and found the Army knife and the list of nine on her person.

Thanks to all who answered. I'd forgotten about the rock incident. So
I guess Shannon was not a "good person," at least not in the eyes of
the Others. I wonder if that knife was the one she tossed to Henry and
if he recognized it.

himiko