Episode # in which Boone died

[d***@aol.com]

What is the episode number in which Boone died? It's the only one I
never saw.

[Fred Ellis]

Post by d***@aol.com
What is the episode number in which Boone died? It's the only one I
never saw.

The episode you are looking for is #20 from the 1st season titled 'Do No
Harm'.


Fred Ellis

[g***@hotmail.com]

Post by Fred Ellis

Post by d***@aol.com
What is the episode number in which Boone died? It's the only one I
never saw.

The episode you are looking for is #20 from the 1st season titled 'Do No
Harm'.

The plane falls and Boone dies, but exactly where was Boone when it
started falling?

[Fred Ellis]

Post by g***@hotmail.com

Post by Fred Ellis

Post by d***@aol.com
What is the episode number in which Boone died? It's the only one I
never saw.

The episode you are looking for is #20 from the 1st season titled 'Do No
Harm'.

The plane falls and Boone dies, but exactly where was Boone when it
started falling?

I guess you didn't watch the episode 'Deux Ex Machina' last season.
Boone was inside the aircraft when it fell from the tree branches over
the side of a cliff. The plane hit nose first and then flipped over
onto its' back. Locke had to crawl inside the aircraft to pull Boone
out. Boone was still alive but critically injured.


Fred Ellis

[g***@hotmail.com]

Post by Fred Ellis

Post by g***@hotmail.com

Post by Fred Ellis

Post by d***@aol.com
What is the episode number in which Boone died? It's the only one I
never saw.

The episode you are looking for is #20 from the 1st season titled 'Do No
Harm'.

The plane falls and Boone dies, but exactly where was Boone when it
started falling?

I guess you didn't watch the episode 'Deux Ex Machina' last season.
Boone was inside the aircraft when it fell from the tree branches over
the side of a cliff. The plane hit nose first and then flipped over
onto its' back. Locke had to crawl inside the aircraft to pull Boone
out. Boone was still alive but critically injured.

That is crazy. I guess there is no wind on this island.

[rwgibson13]

Post by g***@hotmail.com

Post by Fred Ellis

Post by g***@hotmail.com

Post by Fred Ellis

Post by d***@aol.com
What is the episode number in which Boone died? It's the only one I
never saw.

The episode you are looking for is #20 from the 1st season titled 'Do No
Harm'.

The plane falls and Boone dies, but exactly where was Boone when it
started falling?

I guess you didn't watch the episode 'Deux Ex Machina' last season.
Boone was inside the aircraft when it fell from the tree branches over
the side of a cliff. The plane hit nose first and then flipped over
onto its' back. Locke had to crawl inside the aircraft to pull Boone
out. Boone was still alive but critically injured.

That is crazy. I guess there is no wind on this island.

heh, or rain. Or cycles of plant growth that would cause the
vines/tree branches to wither and die :-)

But, in typical Hollywood fashion, we're supposed to believe that the
plane was so delicately balanced that Boone's spending too much time in
the front section was enough to cause it to come loose...

RWG (what the hell, in this show, that's fairly EASY to buy into :-)

[dgates]

Post by rwgibson13

Post by g***@hotmail.com

Post by Fred Ellis

Post by g***@hotmail.com

Post by Fred Ellis

Post by d***@aol.com
What is the episode number in which Boone died? It's the only one I
never saw.

The episode you are looking for is #20 from the 1st season titled 'Do No
Harm'.

The plane falls and Boone dies, but exactly where was Boone when it
started falling?

I guess you didn't watch the episode 'Deux Ex Machina' last season.
Boone was inside the aircraft when it fell from the tree branches over
the side of a cliff. The plane hit nose first and then flipped over
onto its' back. Locke had to crawl inside the aircraft to pull Boone
out. Boone was still alive but critically injured.

That is crazy. I guess there is no wind on this island.

heh, or rain. Or cycles of plant growth that would cause the
vines/tree branches to wither and die :-)
But, in typical Hollywood fashion, we're supposed to believe that the
plane was so delicately balanced that Boone's spending too much time in
the front section was enough to cause it to come loose...
RWG (what the hell, in this show, that's fairly EASY to buy into :-)

I agree. It appears that this island sometimes takes whatever's in a
guy's thoughts and makes it happen in some form. So you could say
that Locke worrying that the plane would fall made it fall.

Of course, if you take that line of thinking much further, it pretty
much allows the writers to do whatever they want. If the *writers*
want something to happen, they can claim that the *island* wanted it
to happen.

[rwgibson13]

Post by dgates

Post by rwgibson13

Post by g***@hotmail.com

Post by Fred Ellis

Post by g***@hotmail.com

Post by Fred Ellis

Post by d***@aol.com
What is the episode number in which Boone died? It's the only one I
never saw.

The episode you are looking for is #20 from the 1st season titled 'Do No
Harm'.

The plane falls and Boone dies, but exactly where was Boone when it
started falling?

I guess you didn't watch the episode 'Deux Ex Machina' last season.
Boone was inside the aircraft when it fell from the tree branches over
the side of a cliff. The plane hit nose first and then flipped over
onto its' back. Locke had to crawl inside the aircraft to pull Boone
out. Boone was still alive but critically injured.

That is crazy. I guess there is no wind on this island.

heh, or rain. Or cycles of plant growth that would cause the
vines/tree branches to wither and die :-)
But, in typical Hollywood fashion, we're supposed to believe that the
plane was so delicately balanced that Boone's spending too much time in
the front section was enough to cause it to come loose...
RWG (what the hell, in this show, that's fairly EASY to buy into :-)

I agree. It appears that this island sometimes takes whatever's in a
guy's thoughts and makes it happen in some form. So you could say
that Locke worrying that the plane would fall made it fall.
Of course, if you take that line of thinking much further, it pretty
much allows the writers to do whatever they want. If the *writers*
want something to happen, they can claim that the *island* wanted it
to happen.

Hey, I've been saying all along that there's probably a sign on the
wall of the production meeting room that says, essentially:

"No matter how improbable, if it is at ALL possible, it CAN happen on
Craphole Island."

RWG (these guys don't like to paint themselves into corners)

[h***@animail.net]

Post by Fred Ellis
I guess you didn't watch the episode 'Deux Ex Machina' last season.
Boone was inside the aircraft when it fell from the tree branches over
the side of a cliff. The plane hit nose first and then flipped over
onto its' back. Locke had to crawl inside the aircraft to pull Boone
out. Boone was still alive but critically injured.

Jack also made a big deal out of the fact that Boone's leg was crushed
by something heavy, not just broken in a fall. He was furious that
Locke had lied about this. Personally, I think Jack was just looking
for excuses for why he couldn't save Boone, but if something in the
plane (the heavy cases of Druggie Marys?) could crush Boone's leg, it
must have some corporeal being.

himiko

[Fred Ellis]

Post by h***@animail.net

Post by Fred Ellis
I guess you didn't watch the episode 'Deux Ex Machina' last season.
Boone was inside the aircraft when it fell from the tree branches over
the side of a cliff. The plane hit nose first and then flipped over
onto its' back. Locke had to crawl inside the aircraft to pull Boone
out. Boone was still alive but critically injured.

Jack also made a big deal out of the fact that Boone's leg was crushed
by something heavy, not just broken in a fall. He was furious that
Locke had lied about this. Personally, I think Jack was just looking
for excuses for why he couldn't save Boone, but if something in the
plane (the heavy cases of Druggie Marys?) could crush Boone's leg, it
must have some corporeal being.
himiko

Go back and watch the episode 'Deux Ex Machina'. As Locke crawls into
the plane he has to move several boxes and crates off of Boone and out
of the way to get to him. I'm sure anyone of them could of crushed
Boone's leg.


Fred Ellis

[h***@animail.net]

Post by Fred Ellis
Go back and watch the episode 'Deux Ex Machina'. As Locke crawls into
the plane he has to move several boxes and crates off of Boone and out
of the way to get to him. I'm sure anyone of them could of crushed
Boone's leg.

Oh, I'm not questioning whether or not his leg was crushed. I'm sure
it was and by the plane or the boxes in the plane...thus confirming
that it's not an illusion of any sort.

I just think Jack's drama queen tirade about how not knowing this in
the first place (because Locke lied) was a rationalization. The reason
Jack couldn't save Boone was because he was dealing with very complex
injuries using only the most primitive medicine...and of course, being
Jack, he thought that was all his fault, so he tried to shift the
"blame" to Locke.

himiko

[Will Bradshaw]

Post by h***@animail.net
I just think Jack's drama queen tirade about how not knowing this in
the first place (because Locke lied) was a rationalization. The
reason Jack couldn't save Boone was because he was dealing with very
complex injuries using only the most primitive medicine...and of
course, being Jack, he thought that was all his fault, so he tried to
shift the "blame" to Locke.

Yes, it was mainly that he was too badly injured to save. But if Locke had
originaly told Jack that Boone had been crushed, not 'fallen off a cliff',
Jack may have been able to do something about his leg before the blood
started building up. Therefore there was a chance that Jack could have
saved him, if Locke had told the truth, because Locke lied Jack did not look
at hs leg first, which was what eventualy killed him.

[Richard DeLuca]

Post by Will Bradshaw

Post by h***@animail.net
I just think Jack's drama queen tirade about how not knowing this in
the first place (because Locke lied) was a rationalization. The
reason Jack couldn't save Boone was because he was dealing with very
complex injuries using only the most primitive medicine...and of
course, being Jack, he thought that was all his fault, so he tried to
shift the "blame" to Locke.

Yes, it was mainly that he was too badly injured to save. But if Locke had
originaly told Jack that Boone had been crushed, not 'fallen off a cliff',
Jack may have been able to do something about his leg before the blood
started building up. Therefore there was a chance that Jack could have
saved him, if Locke had told the truth, because Locke lied Jack did not look
at hs leg first, which was what eventualy killed him.

That may be true, I dunno. Personally, my original take on it was that
here's a man horribly injured, probably dying, who can't talk and
therefore explain what had happened. Along comes Locke with a story
that's obviously untrue, based on the appearance of the injury itself.
I'd be immediately suspicious of foul play too! But Jack did sorta go
off the deep end, didn't he?

[g***@hotmail.com]

Post by Will Bradshaw

Post by h***@animail.net
I just think Jack's drama queen tirade about how not knowing this in
the first place (because Locke lied) was a rationalization. The
reason Jack couldn't save Boone was because he was dealing with very
complex injuries using only the most primitive medicine...and of
course, being Jack, he thought that was all his fault, so he tried to
shift the "blame" to Locke.

Yes, it was mainly that he was too badly injured to save. But if Locke had
originaly told Jack that Boone had been crushed, not 'fallen off a cliff',
Jack may have been able to do something about his leg before the blood
started building up. Therefore there was a chance that Jack could have
saved him, if Locke had told the truth, because Locke lied Jack did not look
at hs leg first, which was what eventualy killed him.

Did Locke actually and intentionally lie?

[Carey Akin]

Post by g***@hotmail.com
Did Locke actually and intentionally lie?

As I recall he did. Remember, he didn't climb up there because his leg
started acting up, and he was limping around.

Carey in Manvel

[h***@animail.net]

Post by g***@hotmail.com
Did Locke actually and intentionally lie?

Yes. He said Boone fell off a cliff. He didn't want the other losties
to know about the drug plane. Why that was so important to him wasn't
quite clear. He was generally secretive about his finds (the hatch
too), possibly because he saw them as mysteries unveiled only to him.
He may also have worried about Charley finding out there were drugs on
the island.

himiko